Wild Duck Creek Springflat Shiraz 2006
$65, Screwcap, 16.5%
I really wanted to like this. I've had the pleasure of a few older (than this at least) Wild Duck Creek reds and actually rather enjoyed them. When I read the ABV on this Springflat though I was worried - I've never had a table wine over about 15% that was remotely balanced. Still, if anyone could do it, surely it would be 'Duck'...
The wine itself smelt superb - Exotic even - with Turkish delight, rhubarb and cherry liqueur chocolates. The palate starts pretty well too, with a very ripe, roasted tomato & red fruit hitting with a first flurry of rich full flavour. But the longer it sits in the glass, the more obviously overripe it becomes, the alcohol acting like a scimitar, cutting off the finish and leaving only blurry heat behind.
On one hand then, this is a major dissapointment - it has that sameness that overripe reds get, where the terroir gets burnt off. But in th other hand. I think this is still an ok wine. It's been shortened no doubt, yet it still drinks like a Heathcote red.
It's damning with faint praise perhaps, but you can just feel how good this wine would be in more supportive vintages, and unlike, say, the unattractively hot Turkey Flat from last week, I comfortably finished two glasses of this. Hard wine to rate then. 16.7
Those rival natural wine fairs (Free for all)
3 hours ago
2009/10 WCA Wine Journalism 'Young Gun; Wine Judge; Gourmet Traveller WINE and Breathe Hunter Valley magazine contributor; LattéLife columnist; National Liquor News Tasting Panellist, WBM Coolest Wine Tweeter of 2010 and Riesling lover who fell into the liquor industry chiefly to buy cheap beer.

seems like this wine is made for the Parker disciples. 16.5% is ridiculous!
ReplyDeleteyou are right, very hard to rate.
tim
I popped a bottle of this on the weekend.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was a very good wine, but in the overblown, fully ripe style you either love or hate.
I don't mind this style every now and then.
Not a great amount of complexity, length or heathcote terroir in evidence- but silky smooth and very enjoyable.
I didn't didn't find the alcohol too offputting- and would have had a lot of 15% that seemed more alcholic, and probably were.
I get an allocation of Springflat each year- the 2007 is a lot more savoury, and more restrained.
The 2006 might not be a wine for the real afficiandos- but my dinner party companions loved it.
If I had of taken along a super complex cote rotie, crozes-hermitage etc I doubt they would have 'got it'.
I'd give it an 18-18.5 for it's style.
Tim Watson