• About Me – Andrew Graham
  • Scoring
  • Contact
  • Editorial Policy + Disclaimer
  • Beer

  • About Me – Andrew Graham
  • Scoring
  • Contact
  • Editorial Policy + Disclaimer
  • Beer

3 faces of the Grampians

August 7, 2010

3 faces of the Grampians

With an unbroken wine history dating back to 1862, the Grampians has no shortage of vinous kudos. Yet, as a wine region it’s in something of a state of flux, with a winemakers association that is being torn apart by internal politics, amidst a generally fragmented community of vignerons.

In this post then I’m going to look – from slightly different angles – at three different Grampians wine producers that I visited last weekend, all with much vested in the region and all producing valid Grampians styles. Hopefully what comes out is a small snapshot of some of the ‘faces’ of this quietly magnificent wine region.

Mt Langi Ghiran

Mount Langi Ghiran cellar door. Stunning

The picture (left) is just one scene from what has to be one of the more dramatic sites in Australian wine.

Mount Langi Ghiran (the estate) is built into the side of it’s namesake: a dramatic granite outcrop sitting near the north eastern boundary of the Grampians region. With a viticultural history that dates back to the 1870s (though with a gap of 75 odd years from the late 1890s to the early 1960s) Mount Langi Ghiran can rightly claim a stake as one of the more important/famous wine producers of the region.

Fittingly, the Mount Langi cellar door itself (as depicted in the photo above/left) is a striking place: Modern, well integrated and set to a stunning backdrop. Striking too, as Mount Langi is an isolated part of the world, in both wine and geographical terms, with the constant winds and spooky looking mountain all making for what is quite a stark – and almost unfriendly – setting.

The whole estate, from a wine point of view, looks special, suggesting that there should be special wine produced here. In all honesty, however, I came away disappointed.

The biggest disappointment lies at the cellar door. For what is a somewhat remote place (45 minutes from anywhere) the range of wines on for tasting is sparse, with only a small selection of the mid priced wines available to sample at the cellar door. I well understand the challenges of quiet cellar doors (and many other Grampians/Pyrenees producers do even more so) but to turn up at such a stunning location, in rural Victoria, and only get to taste a mere sniff of what the site can do feels like a slap in the face. If Langi are worried about wastage, or bus tours or whatever, charge a $5 (or even $10 to taste the top wine) tasting fee to cover costs. I certainly would have paid it.

Anyway, rant over. For those wines that were on tasting (Cliff Edge range mostly) the initial impressions – drawn from the whites – are of purity, expression and flavour, comfortably ticking all the right boxes. But this consistency doesn’t translate into the reds which – to my tastes – are almost ubiquitously overripe.
Obviously the question of ripeness and balance is a subjective one, and I’m hypercritical of anything showing excessive ripeness, but seriously, 15% alcohol on a cool climate Cabernet (as found in the 2005 Langi Cabernet)? Why? All it does it burn off regional/varietal characters, leaving just another boozy new world red.

As if to prove the point, A 2003 Langi Shiraz also consumed over the weekend was suitably dried out, forward and lacking in enough fruit to keep up with the structure, further emphasising the problems of such excesses.

Regardless, it’s a beautiful site, the vines look healthy and the top Langi Shiraz is selling like hotcakes (to considerable critical acclaim). In truth I really want to like these wines, for the mid to late 90’s Langi’s were such impressive things. All it would take is for the same vitality shown in the (early picked) whites to be carried through to the reds. Obviously the winery has a style (one of impact and richness) though and they are sticking by it. It’s just not my favoured style.

(Would be interested to hear other opinions on this. Also interested to try the new 07 and 08 vintage Langi Shiraz – perhaps the balance has been restored?).

The wine highlights:
Mount Langi Ghiran ‘Cliff Edge’ Pinot Gris $25
I really quite enjoyed this. Textural, long and succulent Pinot Gris with pear and honey on a crisp and quite long backbone. Nice wine. Plenty of appeal here.

Clayfield

Simon Clayfield himself
It riles Simon a bit, but the tagline in Halliday’s Wine Companion is that of ‘former Best’s winemaker’, even though he left there back in 1997. But it is relevant for context.

For behind the trademark moustache – and ability to talk underwater – lies a highly experienced winemaker, one who has almost 25 Grampians vintages (many of which were served at Best’s) under his belt and a whole network of local grower contacts to call on.

That last bit is important, for Simon’s own Clayfield vineyard is just 13 years old, and has had only a handful of commercial harvests in that time, due mainly to problems with drought and bushfire. Instead, it has been several old vineyards –  notably the Robinson vineyard on Mt Ararat – that have provided the backbone for the Clayfield wines.

Now Simon, like many of the regions producers, concentrates on Shiraz. In fact, besides a token Pyrenees Sauvignon Blanc, all he makes is Grampians Shiraz. As a result, and given some of the success/critical acclaim his wines has enjoyed over the years, you could call him a Grampians Shiraz expert.

Little wonder then that his wines show the regional style with aplomb. Even in 2008 – which produced plenty of seriously big, alcoholic wines – the regional spiciness is present (though I’m not a massive fan of the two 08 Shiraz, which are just too ripe for me) and the wines taste balanced.

Still, don’t come here looking for elegance, for whilst the alcohol doesn’t generally stand out (08’s excepted), the wines are built unashamedly lavish (but in a good way).

The wine highlights:

Clayfield Shiraz 1999
A back vintage curio, this was one of Simon’s first wines and it was looking in very good shape. Big, still quite firm and dense, with layer upon layer of spicy fruit. Pepper, both black and white, and no shortage of it either. Lovely.

Clayfield Shiraz 2006 ($45)
Take the above wine and subtract 7 years. It’s probably not as spicy as the 1999 – and not likely to end up that way either – but entirely enjoyable in a more luscious style. It’s all about purple plum fruit and no shortage of viscous warmth, but still with solid fruit tannins and a firm line through the finish. Good stuff. Tasty.

Best’s

140 year old Pinot Meunier and Pinot Noir vines

Arguably the leading producer in the Grampians (particularly thanks to the wane of Seppelt’s star post Fosters takeover), you can’t talk about this part of the world without focusing on the (resurgent) Best’s.

I won’t bore you with this wineries history (it’s all here) but suffice to say that Trevor Mast (who owned Langi up until recently) made wine here in the 70’s/mid 80’s and Simon Clayfield made wine here in the late 80’s/mid 90’s, making Best’s particularly pertinent to this story.

What I really want to focus on though is the more recent history. For Best’s, like many successful family wine companies, has basically reinvented itself in recent years, simplifying themselves even.
You can see the results of this process at the winery itself – witness, for example, the large scale, multi thousand litre tanks that sit out next to the winery shed. If you were to take a peak inside these tanks you’d notice that they no longer hold wine and are now full of water. The large airbag presses don’t get much work these days either, with small batches and basket presses utilised for much of the top wines.

Similarly, at cellar door, the cheaper ‘Victorian’ range is being gradually phased out as the ‘Great Western’ range takes more prominence, the winery in effect dragging their whole persona back to where it started at sleepy Great Western.

It’s a smart move – or at least I think so – from a marketing perspective, particularly given that ‘Great Western’ is one of only two specific subregions in Victoria (along with the Nagambie Lakes in the Goulburn Valley), making the area itself even more unique/special.

Wine wise, the ‘Great Western’ range has had some new releases of late too, including a lauded Sparkling Shiraz – that they can’t produce enough of – and a young vine Pinot Meunier. Upcoming additions include a single block 2010 Riesling (which I can confirm is particularly interesting) and a Cabernet blend from some of the oldest Cabernet vines on the Concongella vineyard.

It’s all very positive indeed.

The only challenges for Best’s now is what to do with the – now 80 year old – St Andrews vineyard at Lake Boga (near Swan Hill). What do you do with a major vineyard asset, that now produces grapes that cost more to pick than they do to produce? What a quandary….

The wine highlights

Best’s Bin 0 Great Western Shiraz 1997
Delicious stuff. I believe that it was Campbell Mattinson that talked of ‘plum essence’ as the quintessential Grampians Shiraz character and this is laden with it.

From an exceptional vintage, this shows a spiced plum nose backed by a rich, plum essence palate that is simultaneously sweet and spicy (in contrast to some Grampians Shiraz which can be simply sweet). Still full of primary fruit and topped off with fine tannins, this will make attractive old bones.

Yum (I drank most of a bottle of this).

Best’s Thomsen Family Shiraz 2006
Mid weight, pepper driven Shiraz that is very tightly bound and structure driven, but oh so classic. Will turn out to be a more elegant wine than the 1997 above, in a positive way. Top wine. Long long long termer and drinking at its best 3 days after opening (according to Julian Coldrey who finished the bottle).

Best’s Pinot Meunier 1976

Plucked out of the Best’s cellar last Saturday and drank that night, this was quite decayed on the nose but with a lovely sweet fruited palate. Palate particularly showed prominent acidity, with a trademark Best’s Pinot Meunier treacly bite. Surprisingly, this actually improved with time in the glass, which only enhanced the appeal. Interesting curio and in very good shape.

(I use inklpay in lieu of a paywall. A small tip goes a long way to finally paying for hosting!)

Related Posts:

  • Just dropped: Mount Langi Ghiran Cliff Edge Shiraz 2014
  • Sneak peak at 2012 Torbreck RunRig and more from Game of…
  • Gundog Estate Hunter’s Semillon 2014
  • Vale Simon Burnell

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • WhatsApp
  • Reddit
  • Print
197619971999200320062008GrampiansPinot GrisPinot MeunierShirazTop WineWine
Share

Wine

3 Comments


Red
August 7, 2010 at 1:31 PM
Reply

Really interesting post, in particular the issues with the winemakers association. To my mind the Grampians produces Victoria's best Shiraz, are highly rated by many wine critics, and yet i reckon they have a very low profile amongst the average wine drinking public. A functioning and pro-active winemakers association might be able to change this.
Love Clayfield's shiraz!



Colin r
October 12, 2014 at 10:07 AM
Reply

Hello Andrew,
I smell a rat!
The Mt Langi shiraz (their premium) i have swooned over regularly got more than a little shaky in 2011. I sampled it at cellar door late 2013 early 2014….i believed that it lacked more than the usual wow factor, sure it is subjective but i feel i have sampled enough of these over the years to qualify as something of a fan. It lacked everything i had come to expect and no less pay for over the journey.
So i thought well i would like to check with those on line that know considerably more than i about wine in general.
After many months searching on line i am yet to find a review !!!
Hmmmm……..now looking at Mt Langi www they have moved on to the 2012 mt. Langi at $120-00
As Elmer Fudd said "theres something scwewy going on around here"
I will continue to sing the praises of this wine but i have become a little cynical with this level of…………..no i wont say it!!!



    ozwinereview
    October 12, 2014 at 12:43 PM
    Reply

    '11 very tricky in the Grampians. Very tricky. That '12 langi is a smart wine though..

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Subscribe by email

    Enter your email address:

  • About me – Andrew Graham


    At 18 I started working in a small suburban bottleshop, largely to buy cheap beer. It was my first year of university, doing a degree that I didn't really like, and a liquor shop seemed like fun. Needless to say I discovered wine, my uni degree morphed into something completely different and wine/beer took over my life.

    Almost twenty years later and I currently spend my days wearing many (wine) hats, mostly as a writer, presenter and marketer.

    While wearing my writer cap I write features for the likes of National Liquor News, Gourmet Traveller WINE and the RAS plus I'm a Lifestyle FOOD channel wine expert. Read more about me here or get in touch to book your next wine event with me here.

  • Recent Comments

    • Nina Javez on The drinking thread: 30 smashable Australian wines (for $30 or less) I’d drink on a hot January night
    • Andrew Graham on Almost Club January 2019 edition: A bumper new year of almostness inc. a $500 red
    • Colin Rose on Almost Club January 2019 edition: A bumper new year of almostness inc. a $500 red
    • Andrew Graham on Almost Club January 2019 edition: A bumper new year of almostness inc. a $500 red
    • Simon Colwell on Almost Club January 2019 edition: A bumper new year of almostness inc. a $500 red
  • Categories

    • Beer
    • Wine
  • Archives

  • Tags

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Adelaide Hills Barossa Beer Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet Sauvignon Merlot + Blends Canberra Chardonnay Clare Valley Coonawarra Eden Valley Great Southern Grenache Shiraz + Blends Hunter Margaret River Marlborough McLaren Vale Mega Tasting Mornington Peninsula Pinot Gris Pinot Noir Pyrenees Riesling Rosé Sauvignon Blanc Semillon Shiraz Sparkling Tasmania Top Wine Value pick Wine Wine Yarra Valley



© Copyright Andrew Graham 2018

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.