‘Buttery’ Chardonnay – the Hunter’s secret weapon (feat. Scarborough’s 2011)
When I first entered the wine industry, 15 odd years ago, Chardonnay’s popularity had already peaked. It was still the most consumed white wine mind you, but the change had begun, with tastes moving away from Chardy and into more aromatic/lighter bodied white wines.
Of course that shift did result in the (arguably misguided) Verdelho boom of the late 90s/early noughties (poor Verdelho. Always the chubby bridesmaid), but arguably we ended up with a much more diverse white wine drinking diet because of it (save for the overt dominance of Sauv Blanc).
The main casualty of this taste evolution, however, was the rich, oak (and more oak) driven Chardonnays of the 90s, with wines like Rosemounts Oakasaurus (aka Roxburgh) shuffled into an appropriately full bodied retirement.
While this was a good move in some ways (Chardonnay does not need 100% new oak), the swift abandonment of a mainstream full and ‘buttery’ Chardonnay style left a hole in the market. All those drinkers who prefer softer, more rounded wines were not going to be content drinking dry and sharply defined Sauvignon Blanc, with the Chardonnay styles themselves also becoming drier, leaner and less generous too.
Enter the Hunter Valley vignerons. Despite being regularly viewed more as tourism operators than winemakers, what some of the region’s canny winemakers realised was that the full flavoured style of Hunter Valley Chardonnay had a place after all. Sure, it did require some tinkering (like careful oak treatment and MLF retardation), but what producers like Scarborough, Tyrrell’s, Mistletoe, De Iuliis know is that many people, myself included, prefer Chardonnay to be rich and ripe, the leanings more towards Montrachet than unwooded Chardonnay.
The results of this regional realisation are plain to see. Mistletoe continues to pick up bags of silverware for their Reserve Chardonnay. Tyrrell’s have an ever expanding range of single vineyard Chardonnay, all built full and proudly Hunteriffic. Lake’s Folly Chardonnay now sells out as quick as it did back in the 90s.
Back in the late 90s, when the ABC (Anything But Chardonnay) movement first gathered steam, it seemed to the Scarborough family that their Chardonnay would fall out of fashion. Indeed they started producing a ‘Blue Label’ Chardonnay that was built leaner with less oak and more delicacy in response.
But then a funny thing happened. Instead of ol’ Yellow Label dropping away, sales increased. In fact, sales of full bodied Chardonnay went up so much that Scarborough’s introduced a third, more premium full bodied Chardonnay into the range, tapping into that demand for full-bodied Chardonnay that wasn’t being met elsewhere.
This new 2011 Scarborough Yellow Label Chardonnay is a perfect example of the ‘house style’ too. Produced from a warm vintage in the Hunter (more of a Shiraz vintage than Semillon) it has that ‘buttery’ richness that so many drinkers still love. – a combination of golden, ‘peaches and cream’ fruit and oak, over a palate that is full, low on acid and utterly mouthfilling with its honeyed richness, all without looking sweet or lifeless.
Sure, it’s not minerally, it’s not finely delineated, it’s even a little bulky. But for anyone who can see the charm of Chardonnay with guts, it is a very natural go-to recommendation.
Scarborough Yellow Label Chardonnay 2011
Details: 13.5%, Screwcap, $23CD
Tasted: March 2014
Score: 17.3/20, 90/100
Would I buy it? Yes. Still lots of pleasure here.
HELP KEEP THIS SITE FREE
Rather than using a paywall or bombarding you with ads I simply ask for a small donation via the Paypal link below. Any amount welcome, it all helps keep this site free.
GET A $20 VOUCHER TO SPEND ON WINE
Now at The Wine Collective