$25, Screwcap, 14.5%
Source: Sample
www.serafinowines.com
It took me a while, but I am really warming to these Stelvin Luxe screwcaps. They seem to open with a reassuring thunk-click that feels rather good. Works well with this packaging too.As to the wines, these three reds are sourced from the sprawling Mclarens on the Lake facility, which apparently now numbers over 300 acres under vine (making it one of the biggest in the Vale?). The two 08's in particular are well priced examples of solid McLaren Vale reds, with only the 07 Cab falling off.
First up is the 2008 Shiraz and it's a purple looking beast, the nose thick with tarry, lifted, boysenberry fruit and dominant coconut oak. The palate has some excellent mid palate sweetness, in a grape juice concentrate fashion, before finishing nice and dry.
It's a tad too obvious right now & in need of several more months in the bottle, but no doubting the thick, rich, solid character behind it. With no over-ripeness to be seen and loads of flavour without excess, there is much to like here. Great stuff & good value. Recommended. 17.5/92+
Onto the Cabernet(s) then, and what a contrast between the two - both tasting of their respective vintages, particularly with the 07 which is quite a challenge.
Lighter, redder, faded even when compared to the very purple 08, the 2007 has a rather withdrawn, cedary and leafy nose, smelling lean and just ripe. With air time a herbal, mildly confected red fruit character arises, showing both under and overripeness and reminding how hard it was to get Cabernet fully ripe in 2007.
It's the same on the palate too, with green tannins and a hollow mid palate, edged with the caramel flavours of the odd berry that had become too ripe. The end result is simply hard work, indicative of the perils of mixed ripeness in Cabernet. 14.5/82
The 2008, in contrast, is an entirely different wine. 'Just bottled' purple in colour, the nose here is all about sweet, upfront oak and purple berries, the sweetness of the fruit mingling with the sweet spicy oak in a quite appealing, juicy upfront style.
It's perhaps a bit too sweet on the palate, with blackberry flavours and plenty of oak making for a rather sticky wine that finishes light and rounded. It perhaps lacks the solid class of the 08 Shiraz, but should be quite a pleasant wine with bottle age, though it won't be long lived. Good. 17/90
2009/10 WCA Wine Journalism 'Young Gun; Wine Judge; Gourmet Traveller WINE and Breathe Hunter Valley magazine contributor; LattéLife & The Retiree columnist; National Liquor News tasting panellist and Chablis lover who fell into the liquor industry chiefly to buy cheap beer.
It's good to see those McLaren Vale 08's are still coming along nicely AG.
ReplyDeleteBeck and I spent our first anniversary (pre-Serafino days I think?) at McLarens on the Lake, but I've never quite understood the wines - perhaps a little too 'stereotypical' for me. I know that's not your style either so you might've talked me around on the 08 Shiraz here....
I'm also coming around on these Stelvin-Luxe thingys too....;)
Cheers,
Chris P
What a load of tripe, my wife and I had a bottle of 07 serafino cabernet a couple of nights ago in a restaurant. Not only was it magnificent it rated a 96 from the Advertiser top 100 and James Haliday gave it I think a 91+! I don't know how you came about your accolades Andrew but you obviously know very little about cabernet especially serafino cabernet?
ReplyDeleteLove the enthusiasm Anon!
ReplyDeleteEach to their own of course, but I'm just no fan of under and overripe Cabernets (such as the 07 Serafino). I much preferred the 08.
It looks like there is a fair diversity of opinion about this wine though - would be interested to see some more points of view.
Hi Anonymous,
ReplyDeleteWe just did a blind tasting of the 07 Cab, and Andrew's notes are bang on. Perhaps you have a vested interest? Also, ratings and awards are a dime a dozen - just depends which competitions you're willing to give money and wine to.
WCVR
Anonymous might know a lot about Cabernet, and especially Serafino Cabernet, but I'm not sure I'd be racing out to buy an '07 Cabernet from McLaren Vale in any case, regardless of 96 points from the Advertiser Top 100.
ReplyDeleteIn any case, if you enjoyed the wine, that's the most important thing, isn't it?
The description tells me that Andrew very much knows what he's talking about - classic descriptors of hot-year Cabernet, i.e., when the berries fail to reach physiological ripeness.
MichaelC (who has had no accolades thrust upon him)
Whilst finding Alontin's comments ridiculous, I wouldn't write off a whole region on a general vintage report Michael. That's not entirely sound thought either & I'd suggest a bottle of 2007 Chapel Hill Cabernet as an argument that 07 McLaren Vale has produced something that is not clearly & definitively a "hot-year" wine.
ReplyDelete79/100 from Bob Campbell
ReplyDelete82/100 from me
91/100 James Halliday
96/100 Adelaide Advertiser
Lots of diverse opinions on the 07 Serafino Cabernet
As an Adelaide boy I can attest to seeing some interesting calls in the Advertiser's Top 100. Least of all the likeness of what goes into that list to what is stocked in Cellarbrations liquor stores...
ReplyDeleteSame list which has 2007 Serafino cab at 96 also has 2004 Thomas Hardy cab at 92. Perplexing really.
My favourite call came from the 2007 list, which gave Skillogalee's 2007 Riesling 97 points (Top Wine of Year) in comparison to Grosset's pair of 07s receiving 91 points each.
A fine case of as you say Andrew; 'each to their own'.